Skip to content
Fronts.co

AmericasInsider article10 min read

Between a Rock and a Hard Place: Colombia’s Difficult Choice in 2026

Colombia is heading towards the 2026 presidential elections amid rising violence and growing frustration over the state's inability to restore order.

Between a Rock and a Hard Place: Colombia’s Difficult Choice in 2026

Key insights1 of 4 shown

  1. Colombia's 2026 election presents a choice between Iván Cepeda's negotiation-based security strategy and Abelardo de la Espriella's hard-line military approach.
  2. Locked: for Insiders
  3. Locked: for Insiders
  4. Locked: for Insiders

Colombia is heading toward the 2026 presidential elections amid rising violence and growing frustration over the state’s inability to restore order.

The vote takes place against a backdrop of surging insecurity and a deepening humanitarian crisis. In the Catatumbo region, more than 100,000 people have been displaced, as violence has once again swept through their communities.

That reality now hangs over the campaign, as the country faces a major decision — one shaped by two opposing visions on the central issue of security.

Iván Cepeda represents continuity with the current government’s approach, emphasizing multipartite negotiations with armed groups and structural reforms aimed at reducing inequality. Abelardo de la Espriella, on the other hand, represents a break from that strategy. His proposal is straightforward: a hard-line response to insurgent groups to restore security in regions long neglected by the state.

Echoes of the Past

Security conditions deteriorated sharply in Colombia in 2025. According to Fundación Ideas para la Paz (FIP), the number of members in organized armed groups grew by 23%, reaching 27,000 fighters — the highest figure since the 2016 Peace Agreement. This growth coincided with a 34% increase in armed clashes and the spread of active disputes in 13 areas across the country.

In regions such as Antioquia, Cauca, and Norte de Santander, armed groups expanded their presence, and recruitment intensified in areas where state authority remains weak. Violence resurfaced through local conflicts over strategic corridors, illegal economies, and social control. Today, rural Colombia is facing a humanitarian crisis. Forced displacement increased by more than 85%, while kidnappings rose by 133%, reaching 477 cases. Between December 2025 and January 2026 alone, 1,500 new displacement cases were recorded in the Catatumbo.

Along the Pacific coast, particularly in Chocó and Nariño, armed groups continue exporting cocaine to international markets. The most recent report from the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC), published in 2023, shows coca cultivation reaching 253,000 hectares — the highest level ever recorded and accounting for 67% of the total existing crop.

Such figures are the result of the Paz Total (Total Peace) policy pursued by President Gustavo Petro. Elected in 2022, his approach was built on a clear bet: bring armed groups to the table, secure ceasefires, and reduce violence while negotiations unfolded.

However, dialogue with armed groups failed to produce lasting agreements. While talks were underway with the Ejército de Liberación Nacional (ELN), the group continued operating and maintaining territorial presence. Last year, the ELN called four paros armados (armed shutdowns) across several Colombian departments and along the Venezuelan border. The Estado Mayor Central (EMC) also entered negotiations with the government, but ceasefires were temporary and short-lived.

Violence reached the political class as well. The assassination of Miguel Uribe Turbay reopened wounds many Colombians believed had healed, marking the first assassination of a nationally prominent political figure in Colombia in the 21st century. For many, this signaled a return to a time when political figures were not safe, and when having an opinion could mean death.

A November 2025 poll by Invamer, one of Colombia’s main polling firms, shows that 64.9% of Colombians believe the Paz Total policy is heading in the wrong direction, while 73.7% think the state and its armed forces have lost control over territories where armed groups operate. Yet such seeming unanimity masks a deep divide in Colombian society. In 2016, the plebiscite on the Fuerzas Armadas Revolucionarias de Colombia (FARC) peace deal failed by a razor-thin margin — 50.21% to 49.79% — exposing the country’s deep split over the meaning of peace itself. A decade later, the country is not split over whether it wants to end its decades long conflict, but over how to achieve it, and what it should look like.

An Unfinished Peace

While the 2016 peace agreement formally ended the conflict with the FARC, it did not end Colombia’s armed conflict. The peace accords led to the demobilization of 13,609 fighters, and the surrender of 8,894 weapons. Homicide rates and kidnappings initially fell, and for a moment the country appeared to be entering a post-conflict phase. But the withdrawal of the FARC from their vast rural territories created a vacuum the state struggled to fill.

State presence has been historically weak in rural Colombia, and there was no sustained effort to prevent other armed groups from tightening their grip on key territories.

Loading…

We couldn’t load the rest of this article just now.

Insider article

You've read the first third. Keep going.

Two-thirds of this analysis is still to come, plus 3 more key insights.

Free, no card

Read this free with a Fronts account

Then one Insider article a month. No card, no password.

  1. Enter your email
  2. Read on
  3. Confirm your email later

Make a free account

Already have one? Sign in below.

Fronts Insider

$5 a month · or $50 a year

  • Every Insider article
  • 129 exclusive videos
  • All 883 WarFronts and HomeFronts videos, sponsor-free
  • Cancel anytime. Money back within 30 days.
Duration 16:17Also with InsiderUS Forces are in Colombia and Ecuador. Why?Insider video · watch the previewJoin Insider

Already a member? Sign in and you'll land back here.

Insider article

You've read the first third. Keep going.

Two-thirds of this analysis is still to come, plus 3 more key insights.

Your free article

Read this one free

You get one Insider article a month. Use it here?

Fronts Insider

$5 a month · or $50 a year

  • Every Insider article
  • 129 exclusive videos
  • All 883 WarFronts and HomeFronts videos, sponsor-free
  • Cancel anytime. Money back within 30 days.
Duration 16:17Also with InsiderUS Forces are in Colombia and Ecuador. Why?Insider video · watch the previewJoin Insider